4

What is the differences between the two? Is it model dependent?

9

Tragic Lantern is a fork of the Magic Lantern codebase, which means it was based on ML, but is no longer a part of ML or supported by the ML community. But probably the biggest difference is that from what I can tell, TL development is no longer active (the latest commits I can find, on bitbucket.org are from 2014). I suspect all TL development has moved back to ML.

And yes, just like with its parent project, Tragic Lantern builds are model/OEM firmware-version specific. (See also: Is there a way to get Magic Lantern on my newer model Canon dSLR?)

The main history is that the user "1%" began learning to code and chose to use the ML code base as his first project, because he had an (at the time) unsupported 7D and wanted to see if he could add it. 7D users rejoiced. He made a lot of progress (not just on the 7D, but also the 6D and EOS M) and did amazing things, but he was inexperienced and not versed in two major things that caused trouble down the line.

The first issue was that while he knew how to download the codebase and develop from it, he wasn't versed in open source practices, and did not habitually push code back to the main ML development effort for review and inclusion into the main ML development repository. As a result, as time went by, TL got more and more out of sync with ML, and trying to roll in his new features (on old code) eventually became more effort than simply rewriting from scratch in the current codebase.

The second issue was that he activated some features by simply ignoring known bugs. So TL had features that ML chose not to activate for safety reasons. In the main thread on the Tragic Lantern fork on the ML messageboards, "a1ex" (the main contributor to ML) pointed out that 1% had, for example, enabled WAV recording, which was known to write to unallocated memory. Without fixing the issue first. (As far as I can gather as a non-programmer, 1% misinterpreted the situation and thought he was disabling the write capability, not just an error message).

Naive users of the models that only TL supported or who wanted the features TL has that ML doesn't, of course, complained, and gave anecdotal "evidence" that since their TL-equipped cameras hadn't crashed, clearly the code was safe. 1% was also putting up with some harsh criticism and felt that his efforts were unappreciated, while the ML developers were upset about all the wasted effort that could have (from their POV) been avoided. But basically, it was a huge mess of hurt feelings and a Big Learning Experience for all. And forking TL off as a separate open-source project was the cleanest way of getting out of the mess. And then everyone rolled up their sleeves and started working on backporting 7D features from TL.

Today, ML supports the 6D, 7D, and EOS M. And is still very actively developed. Unless you rely on one of the TL features that isn't active in the ML code, then you should probably stick with ML.

  • 1
    Welp, looks like my answer below gets a lot wrong. I only remember what I read a couple of years ago as I was browsing the forums looking for a build for the 1200D. I think I should delete my answer. – salmonlawyer Aug 17 '18 at 2:18
  • @salmonlawyer, alternate views of history. :D – inkista Aug 17 '18 at 18:51
  • @salmonlawyer, BTW, if you hadn't written your answer, I wouldn't have written mine.Wrong answers can still be useful as strawman/stalking horse targets for others to aim at. – inkista Aug 19 '18 at 2:49
  • Well thank you for making me feel better about that. – salmonlawyer Aug 19 '18 at 4:01
  • 1
    @salmonlawyer, de nada. I've put up strawman answers both inadvertently and deliberately here; but I'm a battled-hardened 20+-year veteran of the professional tech writing (excuse—technical communications) profession. We know all the stratagems for prying information out of overworked engineers. :) – inkista Aug 19 '18 at 20:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.