What's the safest orientation for storing a lens in a bag?

Question

You may think that I am a bit crazy, but every single time that I carry more than one lens with me (and I like doing that, since changing lenses is part of the fun :-) ) I cannot avoid to wonder if it's better (as in "safest") to place the unmounted lenses top or bottom up in the camera bag.

So, what do you suggest? What's worse for a lens, receiving an eventual bump/shock on the glass side or on the body side? Or: how do you choose which side they go?

Obviously I am not thinking about dropping the bag/backpack from some height, but to the normal kind of stresses to which a bag is exposed day-to-day.

ps: I have added some layers of bubble wrap to pad the bag (and backpack) but my obsessive self is still not happy, even if I am rationally aware that the difference, if it exists at all, must be very small.

pps: bonus points for answers covering other equipment, like flashes, etc...

Answer 1

*First I'll say that this is mostly preference and you should take all answers into consideration.

Regardless, a proper bag should be used. A proper bag has at least 1/4" padding on the outside and separation for all lenses. The outside should have rigid panels to prevent flexing and distribute force from bumps. It should have strong zippers to prevent separation during travel.

Lenses should be stored to prevent telescoping. The best way to prevent this is to store the lens face down and keep the weight of the lens to prevent telescoping.

Damage to the lens element is unlikely when you have a lens cap and a proper bag with at least 1/4" padding. In order to damage a lens through the cap, a blunt force must be applied only to the center and not the ring of the lens. This is unlikely in a bag and why most camera bags have rigid panels, distributing force.

Keeping lenses face down also allow easier access for swapping of lenses since you can swap rear caps without removing the lens from the bag. Lenses should not be stored with hoods attached for long periods of time or further travel. Blunt force could damage the hood threads.

Padding should be aligned to prevent any two lenses from bumping. The force of two lenses hitting is a lot greater if there is no padding. The lenses should also have designated spaces that fit them snugly.

Flashes should always be stored straight and not in an angled position. Blunt force in any manner in an angled flash can damage the locking mechanism along with electronics.

Filters should be kept in their original cases for storage and hoods can be stacked inside each other loosely.

Answer 2

What I do with my camera bag is grab divisions from older bags and give the lenses some extra padding, theres usually a lot of room to do this, also always keep the caps on the lenses, they provide sturdiness on the ring, even better, get UV filters. However, theres a small thing I don't do, I never put the lenses on the bottom of the bag, if I drop the bag, it's most likely that it will hit bottom first.

Answer 3

If you're not going to drop the equipment, it doesn't matter (I use Domke wraps). If you are going to drop the equipment, again it doesn't matter. Just make sure the lens rolls when it hits the ground, and it might be fine. :) I've had a camera/lens roll down a tripod about 6' to a marble floor, and both survived. Not just survived, but there are absolutely no signs of any damage that affect image quality. I've had a camera/lens drop 2 ft onto concrete and roll down an inclined slope. Again, no effect on image quality. That said, I wouldn't recommend doing either one. :) If you drop your equipment, luck plays a major role. If you don't drop it, loosely pad it so that equipment doesn't scrape against each other.