Are the sliders (shadows/highlights) in Adobe Camera Raw affecting the device-dependent data before transformation to device-independent color space, or does this transformation happen after the input data was already converted to a device-independent working space?

If the latter, does the TRC of the input->independent conversion matter for the correct functionality of the sliders? In other words, do they expect a delinearized camera input profile?

I would be interested in creating a flat input profile for my camera, for example using DCamProf, but before going through all that effort I'd like to know if Adobe Camera Raw would be confused by a flat TRC.


To answer my own question, no, you can't work in ACR/Lightroom with a linear input profile.

From the developer of DCamProf on a Luminous Landscape thread.

All Adobe's profiles apply a curve, and afaik all have subjective tunings too to provide a pleasing color appearance with that curve applied. You can't really work in Lightroom with a linear colorimetric profile and get good color appearance for general purpose photography, as all the tools to apply contrast will distort color in one way or another.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.