0

Recently I was looking for some used 85A filters to shoot tungsten film outside. My primary consideration are ones made by Hoya because they are good quality, abundant and relatively inexpensive. But I would prefer those that have multi-coating.

Some older Hoya filters (those with older Hoya logos) have the HMC marking on them, like modern ones, but most others do not.

Any idea what type of coating do older non-HMC-marked Hoya filters have?

Hoya had many different packaging designs and several different logos over the years. Some filters have HMC marking, some don't, and some have things like "This filter is coated on both sides" written on the packaging. It's all a little confusing. Were any of the non-HMC-marked filters actually multi-coated?

  • Some of those older Hoya filters have coatings that are somewhat fragile - I messed one up pretty bad with an alcohol wipe once. Just thought that might be worth pointing out... – junkyardsparkle Nov 26 '17 at 21:47
  • @junkyardsparkle thanks, it's actually very helpful info, considering that I usually clean my lenses/filters with either pure isopropyl alcohol (rubbing alcohol), or, in rare cases, ethanol. – lightproof Nov 27 '17 at 22:22
  • I should also mention that this was on an ND filter; I'm not sure if it applies to something like 85a filters or not, but somebody probably knows... – junkyardsparkle Nov 28 '17 at 1:43
2

"Multi-coated" doesn't primarily reference a filter that has a coating on more than one side. It means each coated surface has multiple coating layers on the same surface.

Each of these multiple coatings are used to control reflections of the various wavelengths of light. Just as refractive lenses bend light slightly more or less depending on the different wavelengths of light, different coating materials will be more effective at certain wavelengths and less effective at other wavelengths. By using multiple layers that are each optimized for different ranges of the wavelengths of visible light, a multi-coated surface can suppress reflections more or less equally across the entire visible spectrum.

A filter could have a single layer coating on both surfaces and would still not be considered a true 'multi-coated' filter.

Were any of the non-HMC-marked filters actually multi-coated?

Probably not. If the coated surfaces have more than one coating layer Hoya would almost certainly have labeled the filter as 'HMC' rather than "...coated on both sides."

  • I know what multi-coating is, it was just curious to find the mention of coating on both sides. Anyway, thanks for the info, I think I'll stick to HMC filters. – lightproof Nov 27 '17 at 22:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.