I probably don't exactly understand the nuances of RAW. In my Olympus OM-D EM-10 I sometimes play around with some of the crazy effects that the camera can apply to the image.

I would have thought that those effects would appear only in the JPEG and not in the Raw image. But that's not the case. Can someone explain what's going on there? Thanks!

  • 1
    What effects are they and what RAW converter are you using? – Please Read My Profile Jun 5 '16 at 16:50
  • The case I am studying is the so-called key-line art filter. And the converter is what's built into Apple's OS X Photos app. (By the way my camera is the Olympus OM-D EM-10. – pitosalas Jun 5 '16 at 20:36

Are the effects really being applied, or are they just showing up in the preview image of the application you use? For example, I can apply in-camera effects to my RAW images, and these effects will appear in my RAW editing software (Adobe Bridge & Camera Raw) as a preview image. Once opened for editing though, the edit disappears. Have you tried opening the file in Photos' edit mode to see if the effects disappear?

| improve this answer | |

A RAW file contains sensor data which is not affected by effects. To speed up preview though, nearly all RAW files store an embedded JPEG to which effects are usually applied to coincide with what the camera settings are. It also used images parameters, including color modes, WB and selectable tone curve as you can edit them in the E-M10.

The tricky part is that some RAW development software also use the preview to show the image until it has been converted, so it looks like the effect is applied when in fact it is not. Lightroom is known to show a different preview in the Library module than in the Develop one, although the extent to which it does this may depend on the camera.

| improve this answer | |

The thing you've got to remember is that you never really see a "raw" file on your monitor when using an application that handles raw file editing and conversion. (Yes, there are ways to view linear, un-demosaiced luminance values on a monitor. Even then there needs to be some compression of dynamic range to fit 12-14 bits of dynamic range into 8 bits. But anyone doing so already knows the answer to this question, and that isn't what this question addresses.)

What you see is a particular conversion of the monochromatic luminance values contained in the raw file: demosaiced to create color information, gamma correction applied (unless you select the "linear" option if offered), and various other light curves (contrast, saturation, etc.) applied.

It takes more than a brief instant for most computers to process the data in the raw file and produce a viewable image on your screen. What most applications do during this interim is display a preview jpeg image created by the camera and appended to the raw file at the time the photo was taken. This in-camera jpeg preview will have the various in-camera settings selected at the time of image captured applied. It is also this preview that you normally see on the camera's rear LCD screen when reviewing images in-camera.

Once the application has interpreted the actual raw data in the file it will either continue to display the preview image or it may change over to displaying the interpretation of the raw data it has created based on a particular set of parameters. These parameters may be the in-camera settings, they may be a default setting of the application, or a particular user created profile the application has been instructed to use. It all depends on the application in question and the settings the user has selected.

If the user subsequently alters a setting, the application will modify the displayed image to reflect the change. Sometimes it will reinterpret all the raw data with the new parameters applied. Sometimes it will simply adjust the image already rendered a little brighter or dimmer, more or less saturated, etc. depending on what was changed. Sometimes it will do the latter while it recomputes the raw data and then do the former. Again, it all depends upon the application and the user selected settings.

If the preview image is never replaced, try opening the image in an edit module of your application.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.