2

Why does lightoom 6 not keep my custom crop size. I want to print A1 (841mmx594m) size so I set an equivalent custom aspect ratio (8.41 x 5.94) and that worked okay. But then I realized I needed a 5mm per side bleed (51mmx604mm) so I changed aspect ratio to 8.51 x 604, but Lightroom keeps changing it to 7 x 5. Now whilst very similar 7x 5 is not the same ratio as 8.51 x 6.04, i.e 851/7 = 121.57, whereas 604/5 = 120.8, so if I multiple 7 and 5 by the lower ratio I get 845.6 x 604 so Ive lost 5.5mm from the landscape length

Why does it do this ?

Edit I wonder if it just accurate to two decimal places and doesn't round up, so these are the dimensions

841/594 = 1.4158 851/604 = 1.4089 7/5 = 1.40

and as you can see the last two are the same to two decimal places if don't round up, but they are different if I do round up.

If I set the aspect to 1 x 1.41 then Lightroom doesn't change it to 7x5, and I think this is close enough as 1 x 1.41 is the same as 851.64 x 604

2

This has been a known problem in Lightroom for over 2 years, with no response from Adobe.

I'm not sure what the precision is, but if you're too close to a standard aspect ratio it just uses the standard ratio. I needed to do a 13x10 crop and LR refused to store it as a custom ratio, always choosing 8½x11 instead. Curiously, 8½x11 is 1.29412 so 2 decimal places should have been enough to differentiate between the two. It's not clear what's going on under the covers.

According to one comment on the Adobe forum from 2 years ago, older versions (LR3 and before) don't exhibit this behavior.

| improve this answer | |
  • thankyou foir alerting me that its a known problem, shame noone knows exactly what the problem is though – Paul Taylor Apr 29 '16 at 19:35

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.