2

I've bought a Sigma 18MM 3.5F Ø72mm Autofocus for a Canon SLR. The thing is that I've got a Canon 40D so I made a mistake I think.

The lens only works the aperture is set to f/3.5; any other aperture setting results in an Err 01:

Err 01

Communications between the camera and lens is faulty.
Clean the lens contacts.

Is there any way (setting) or hardware to fix this?

Or should I take my loss and try selling it on ebay? enter image description here

enter image description here enter image description here

  • 2
    I've got an older Sigma 70-300 that does the same: Will only work on my digital EOS bodies if I shoot in manual exposure mode with the aperture all the way open. It works fine on my older EOS film body. – Michael C Jun 7 '15 at 19:18
  • This is exactly why I've resisted buying the Sigma 50mm f/1.4 DG HSM Art Lens. Amazing performance for the price, but too many people say that Sigma have trouble keeping up with new Canon bodies. – Arkanon Jun 7 '15 at 23:22
  • hehe! a win for Nikon then... mechanical iris control :-D – Digital Lightcraft Jun 9 '15 at 16:31
  • 1
    @arkanon: "Sigma have trouble keeping up with new Canon bodies" - I'd better say that Canon does not keep the protocol consistent. – Euri Pinhollow Mar 25 '16 at 17:15
6

You want to contact Sigma and find out if they'll still rechip the lens.

Given the age of the lens and the fact that you're not the original owner, they may not be able to rechip it, or might charge for it, but it's worth a shot--the worst they can do is say no. Third party lens makers typically reverse engineer the electronic communication between the lens and the body--they're not privy to the full design the way the OEM is--and chances are that when Canon added the digital EF-S stuff to the mount communication, they broke compatibility with the then-current Sigma lenses.

Some third party lenses are only compatible with the mount system at the time they're made, but may not be so great with the mount as it was ten years ago or will be ten years into the future. While Canon will probably try to make sure their own lenses have backwards/forwards compatibility, they're not going to care about third parties. This is why some third party brands build in the capability for firmware upgrades on their lenses/flashes. But backwards compatibility with older Sigma lenses, particularly on AF function, is known to be an issue. Sigma at the time of the switchover problem, offered to rechip lenses for free, but may no longer do so.

2

This is old question but problem is still actual on old lenses. What you need is protocol interface which converts aperture change command from camera to lens. Please see my article at this link where is problem cause and it's solution described in detail http://butterflybikers.cz/index.php/cz/elektronika/item/1-canon-eos-protocol-convertor-for-old-sigma-lens .

For those who don't want to read whole article I will try to describe problem in short. Old EOS cameras (at moment we can say very old) was using different digital command on SPI bus which tell lens to adjust aperture to some value. For some reason Canon changed that command (old was 0x12 new is 0x13). Result is that your old 3rd party lens is unable to set aperture so gets ERROR 01 because camera cannot set aperture in lens. Solution is easy, add processor to signal path which will convert new command to old one so lens will understand it. See link above for more technical details, HW and SW sources.

-1

I just tried a Sigma 28-105/3.8-5.6 UC-III of 1999 vintage. On 5D Mark II the aperture does not operate. I got an Err 01 after the exposure. With Metabones Mark IV adapter and Sony A6300, however, the aperture works fine. So one way to use those very old Sigmas is to use them on a Sony.

  • Interesting comparison detail, but it doesn't address the original question of getting the lens to work on a Canon 40D. – scottbb Mar 25 '16 at 13:53
-2

Have you got the latest firmware for the camera? If not, try updating it. http://www.canon.dk/support/consumer_products/products/cameras/digital_slr/eos_40d.aspx?type=firmware

  • Yes I have got the latest version v1.1.1. – Ralf de Kleine Jun 7 '15 at 16:15
  • 5
    This is not a camera issue: this is a known issue with older third party lenses, particularly Sigma made for Canon EOS EF mount. If anything, the older firmware for the camera might be more compatible with an older lens than the newer firmware would be. – Michael C Jun 7 '15 at 21:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.