3

I know that I can store metadata in the file itself (or in an XMP sidecar file) by pressing Cmd/Ctrl+S. Or by choosing Metadata -> Store Metadata in File from the menu.

I wonder why I need to choose this manually. I did not find any way to set this as a default. Compared to Bridge or pretty much any other metadata-oriented tool, this seems like a disadvantage. I know that the data gets stored in the catalogue, but I'd rather have it in the files as well!

Am I overlooking something? Can I set Lightroom up in a way that does this automatically?

2

Lightroom can certainly do that - look at Catalog settings -> Metadata -> Editing -> Automatically write changes to XMP.

  • 1
    Just be aware that this may have a really big impact on your system when you make changes to a lot of files at once (eg. when you rename a tag). In this case, gigabytes of data may need to be rewritten. – ths Jun 4 '15 at 16:02
  • But i would have to remember to check this setting, whenever i start a new catalog? (granted that will not happen regularly) – amenthes Jun 4 '15 at 18:06
  • So even though this option says "write changes to XMP," it also means overwrite metadata changes to supported file types? – feetwet Jul 8 '17 at 19:05
2

You can also NOT tick the auto write changes to XMP for performance and integrity reasons BUT set up a Smart Collection of Metdata Status IsNot Up to date. Then periodically select that Smart Collection then Select All and then Cmd/Ctrl - S.

I should have mentioned that after some edits, I back up LR and images, then do a mass update of meta-data via Cmd/Ctrl - S, then do another backup of the images. The reason for this is that if you have some kind of HD failure while writing the meta-data you could lose the image that is why I back up before and after. In reality the before backup simply checks to make sure the existing backup is the same as the master.

  • that's interesting! I like that. Still keeping the other answer as "accepted", as it's more automatic and will (hopefully) suffice for my needs. But i very much appreciate this answer! – amenthes Jun 15 '15 at 19:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.