2

I have a Canon AE-1 film camera. It works well and I've several FD, FL and Vivitar lenses.

For recent digital cameras, I know how the light meter works. However, with this old camera, I would shed light on one specific point.

For full-aperture metering, the meter does the measurement with light rays that come through the lens. There are 4 factors:

  • ISO/ASA (known by the camera)
  • speed (also known)
  • quantity of light (what is actually measured)
  • aperture (not known by the film camera ...)

You see where I'm going here. In full-aperture metering, aperture is a factor that depends on the lens and can vary ! I've some 1.4, 1.8, 2.8 and 3.5 lenses. How the light meter can do a correct computation without knowing the aperture of the lens ?

For example, on a sunny day with 100 ASA film, 1/1000 speed and my f/1.4 lens, the light meter of my AE-1 will indicate f/5.6. But if I take another lens, e.g. a f/2.8 one, the quantity of light receive by the light meter will be less than with the previous one... Thus, it will indicate may be f/4 or f/2.8, or some other value. And one of the readings must be wrong, no?

3

This depends on the lens mount. The Canon FD mount has two mechanical communication paths from the lens to the camera:

  • An Aperture Signal Lever that tells the camera whether the lens is at full aperture or, if not, how much it is stepped down.
  • A Full Aperture Signal Pin that tells the camera what its full aperture actually is - so the camera does know! When connected, it depresses a matching pin in the camera body. In variable-aperture zoom lenses, working the zoom moves this pin.

The details are explained on this page.

Note that FL mount lenses to not have the Full Aperture Signal Pin, so with such a lens, your meter actually shouldn't be able to tell you what aperture to set, only how much to stop down (or up).

  • Thank you for your response. Indeed, my question was about my FL lenses (which work with full-aperture metering). With these lenses, as you said, the camera doesn't know the aperture. Is there no technique / tips to deduce which aperture set with the meter info ? If I take a 3.5 FL 17mm lens, if the AE-1 meter level show "5.6", I know that I must stop down, but how could I know the best aperture ? – AntiClimacus May 3 '14 at 21:40
  • @AntiClimacus: Actually, according to the Canon website (kbsupport.cusa.canon.com/system/… ) you definitely cannot use full-aperture metering with an FL lens - instead you use stopped-down metering, which basically means you have to vary aperture until the meter shows 5.6 - that means that your current aperture is correct, not that you have to change it. – Michael Borgwardt May 3 '14 at 22:04
  • Ok ! Last question: I'm just curious to know the default value of the full aperture signal pin, when I use a FL lens. Indeed, with the knowledge of this default value, I could use it to compute myself the best aperture (with the aperture info of meter). E.g., if this value is f/1.8, I can directly use the meter light information with my 1.8 FL lens :D – AntiClimacus May 3 '14 at 22:14
  • @AntiClimacus: sorry, can't help you with that, not sure if there is such a default behaviour. – Michael Borgwardt May 3 '14 at 22:36
  • Your link is dead (March 2018) – MicroMachine Mar 19 '18 at 17:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.