3

What curves do photographers use when modifying the contrast of their photographic images?

The simple equation y = a*x + b is sometimes with a as "contrast" and b as "brightness", but that's not what's happening here. So I'd like to as if anyone has seen an expression for a more "professional" contrast curve, that's written in the form of an equation.

Wile many photographers either use what a program provides with sliders or they manipulate the contrast curve by grabbing on to points and moving it around, I was wondering if there are some standard way of generating a set of smooth curves to change the contrast photos.

4

What curves do photographers use when modifying the contrast of their photographic images?¹

The vast majority don't do their own curves programmatically, which seems to be what you are seeking.

Instead, most start with a "canned" default curve, such as your example of y = a*x + b, applied by their chosen raw processing application, and then either use the "shadows", "highlights", "black point", "white point" sliders provided by various application and/or they draw their own curves freehand with a "curves" tool.

It may be fairly pedestrian, or it could wind up looking fairly radical. They may apply the same curve to all three color channels, or they may apply different curves to each color channel. In each case, it's usually a fairly specific custom curve created for the contents of a specific image and how various tonal values (brightnesses) are distributed within that image or within a group of very similar images shot of the same scene under the same lighting conditions.

Here's an example of a tone curve tool in Adobe After Effects that has a moderately modified curve applied to all channels (the gray line) and separate curves drawn for the red, green, and blue channels.

enter image description here

The result from the above curve tool adjustment would be to raise the red channel overall, raise the green channel inthe highlights while reducing it in the lower tones while at the same time reducing the blue channel inthe highlights while increasing it in the shadows.

It's from this tutorial titled: A Beginner’s Guide to Curves for Color Correction. Though the tutorial is more video centric, the concept applies to stills and video equally.

Here's a really radical curve drawn for the purpose of just showing what can be done with "fixed point" curve tools.

enter image description here

There's also a good 'Photoshop Curves' tutorial at Cambridge in Colour that shows how the curves tool can be used with images that have a "gap" in the middle of the histogram:

enter image description here

If the gaps occur in between tonal peaks, then a unique ability with curves is that it can decrease contrast in these unused tones — thereby freeing up contrast to be spent on tones which are actually present in the image.

enter image description here

The above curve moves this photo from the image on the left, using a "flat" curve, to the image on the right with the curve applied:

enter image description here enter image description here

One can also use an HSL/HSV/HSB (Hue-Saturation-Luminance/Value/Brightness) tool to further adjust hue, saturation, and luminance of each of about eight different color bands. This has a similar effect of a single point curve for that specific range of colors within each band.

So while many photographers either use what a program provides with sliders or they manipulate the contrast curve by grabbing on to points and moving it around, my way of interfacing with technology is different and I'm more comfortable with mathematics and with manipulating the images in a more hands-on way. I can try variations with different expressions or different coefficients and see their impact on the final image in real time. But I'd like a tried-and-true contrast curve-generating equation to start with, so I'm asking for help finding one.

I'm not aware of any professional photographers who take such an approach to which I can point you. I've certainly never seen any tutorials to that effect.

¹ I edited this phrase into the question based upon this comment made by the OP the comments beneath the question: "The question I want to ask is what curves photographers use when modifying the contrast of their photographic images and I think that's exactly what the question currently asks. I don't think it was clear at all that you were asking this, because the vast majority of professional photographers don't programmatically apply curves using mathematical formulae, unless you consider drawing a custom curve by hand and/or using sliders and then saving that custom curve in order to apply it to other, similar images.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    +1 while it's not the answer I was hoping for this is certainly an answer I should embrace. Thank you very much for your help! I think that a at least one message I need to take from this is that the issues one might want to address vary so much from one photo to the next and even from one area of a photo to another that there is no single "contrast curve" in general use, nor even a set of them. Instead manipulation is generally quite hands-on and specific. And that's true even before addressing individual color channels. – uhoh Jul 29 at 9:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.