1

I'm interested in trying macro photography, but I don't want to invest into Macro-objectives yet.

Can I get satisfying results using Kenko extension tubes in combination with a Sigma 50mm art 1.4? Are there any other recommendations? A local second hand store offered me a used Kenko set with AF, and the price is not bad at all.

  • 1
    in combination with what camera do you want to use it? what do you define as satisfying? what do you want to photograph? could you please give us more information and extend the question with it. possibly with a sample image u think is satisfying – LuZel Nov 13 at 8:03
  • It seems the Art 50mm f1.4 is an internal focus design. Such lenses can yield all kind of unwelcome surprises when used off their specified flange distance. Extension tubes are best used with so called unit focusing lenses (which focus by varying the distance of the whole objective from the film plane). – rackandboneman Nov 13 at 9:17
  • 2
    "Can I get satisfying results..." – This depends on your preferences. The only way for you to know if you'll be satisfied is to try it. – xiota Nov 13 at 15:58
  • 2
1

Extension tubes, so long as they make electrical connection, affect nothing except the amount of light that actually reaches the camera sensor. They have no influence on anything other than the focussing distance.

Because of that, yes, 68 mm of extension tube will get you very very close indeed on a 50mm lens, in fact I've found 50mm to be about the break-point on 68mm tubes.
You may find you have to remove the 12mm, as at 68mm, the far-point for focussing might actually be inside the lens, or so close you keep banging into things.

The fact that it claims to be able to carry the AF information you will quickly discover is more a theory than a fact. It will try to AF, but will almost never work. You are far better off going full manual for macro work. You will also need a lot of light.

If you are outdoors, then you might have to rely on a ring-flash & a bit of guesswork for focus. Indoors I use constant video lighting so I can see my focus easily through the viewfinder.
60-odd mm on a 50mm lens & your DoF is going to be measured in millimetres or less, even stopped down to f/5.6 or f/8, where most of this type of lens is at its sharpest, so you will need a tripod & either a macro rail or use manual focus pull to generate focus stacks.
If you are outdoors or trying to capture something moving, you might need to sacrifice some of the extension so you can get a deeper DoF & shoot from further away to get your subject in frame.

I normally focus stack to get sharp right the way through but this one I did in a single shot to capture just one element in focus, so you can see how shallow each slice of a focus stack would be. This was done on a Nikon 50mm 1.4 at f/4 & either 56 or 68mm extension [I didn't document it at the time]
I actually did this hand-held & just took a couple of dozen shots once I'd got my lighting right, until I got one with the 'happy accident' focussing I liked the most

enter image description here

Incidentally, my extension tubes are just 'mickey mouse' cheap tubes from eBay. I think I paid maybe $£€ 25 for them. They have metal mounts, but are plastic otherwise - but they don't wobble, don't let in light & carry the electrical data, so my AF works [in theory] but more importantly my aperture & exposure meters work correctly. As all you are really buying is an air gap not a lens of any sort, I didn't see the need to buy anything more expensive.

  • Yes, you can get excellent results with an extension tube (I have only used a 50mm 1.8). Besides what Tetsujin mentioned, you will find that the focus adjustment on the lens will have very little effect. Most of your focusing must be accomplished by altering the distance to the subject. I use a focusing rail for this. – Mattman944 Nov 13 at 9:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.