8

I have a SanDisk SD Card 64gb UHS 3, 3 years old.

From someday, it became unusable on a Panasonic Lx100 — but it works right on my other camera (a Pentax K-70). On the LX10, I get an error: "Error writing on sd card".

I've tested it on Windows and max write speed is 2 mbyte/s, so performance is degraded (it should go to at least at 30-40 mbyte/s).

Is there something I can do to solve this situation ?

  • 8
    SD cards, even high capacity ones, are a commodity nowadays. Why do you wish to save your failing SD card? – MonkeyZeus Nov 4 at 20:39
  • 6
    @MonkeyZeus Commodity in western countries. Comparatively 6x more expensive in India than in the EU, for instance, if you compare the salary of a software developer in the EU and in India. – xenoid Nov 4 at 23:38
  • 3
    tbh, cost shouldn't be a factor in this. Once these things start to fail, they fail fast & irreversibly, often irretrievably too. Never store your only copy of any data on one & always bin them at the first sign of failure. – Tetsujin Nov 7 at 9:01
  • Cards (and just about any other storage device in use) have a limited lifespan. Yours is reaching the end of it's. – Mast Nov 7 at 15:31
50

Yes, there's something you can do. Stop using the card and replace it. Even reputable, high-quality cards have failures. And every such device has a limited lifespan. Don't risk it. You may do something which will cover up the problem, only for it to reoccur and cause you to lose images.

SanDisk offers a long warranty in most countries — depending on the card and country, seven to thirty years if not lifetime. So, since yours is only three years old, you should be able to send it in for replacement.

  • 28
    Also, always migrate your photos to more reliable media at the earliest opportunity. Leaving your last 10 years of precious photos on flash media of pretty much any type is just asking for problems at some point. – twalberg Nov 4 at 18:19
12

Is there something I can do to solve this situation ?

Get another card.

  • 1
    +1 SD cards are expendables nowadays. For fewer money one can get higher capacity and higher speeds. – Crowley Nov 4 at 22:02
9

Good (not super) quality 64GB cards are around 10 to 14 "generic bucks" (US Dollars, Euros, UKP). "Good quality" defined as "built as designed by a reputable brand, no reason to expect b grade product or counterfeits". This actually puts the usefulness of reusing them at all in question - instead of using them once, periodically downloading and until they are full, then physically archiving them as additional backup.

They take around 1500-2000 images even when shooting raw (unless we are talking very high res cameras), even more when doing JPEG only or JPEG mostly. The time investment in 2000 frames (or hours of video), no matter whether it is professional or enthusiast work, probably exceeds 12 bucks significantly. On some cameras, the cost from shutter wear could exceed 12 bucks for 2000 frames.

Also, take (mental or written) notes what card brand/model works reliably (or) not with which of your cameras ... mechanical and electrical tolerances can do a lot for or against you here....

  • 1
    1) Are there figures of their long-term durability as dormant storage? And 2) polluttion. Your heirs will dump them :) Mine will just inherit a couple of hard disks. – xenoid Nov 4 at 23:29
  • Why would there be a great difference compared to SSDs, if you do not exhaust the memory cards with heavy write cycling? Also, the volume of one 10 TB 3.5" harddrive will absorb a lot of microSD cards :) – rackandboneman Nov 5 at 9:51
  • 2
    The durability of unplugged SSDs doesn't look that good. Looks like we will need a SSD cellar next to the wine one. – xenoid Nov 5 at 10:19
  • Please clarify the currency used in this post. – Lightness Races with Monica Nov 5 at 11:24
  • 2
    @SztupY Note that this is a photography site, so answers should be in that context. For video, there is Video Production – mattdm Nov 6 at 6:04
5

Backup your data now. What capacity out of the 64GB has already been written? Maybe you bought a fake one and the real capacity has been reached, so you get sudden failure. These fakes often appear larger, (e.g. 32GB instead of 64GB, or even 8GB instead of 64GB), then once the small capacity is filled, they lie to the user and overwrite the EXISTING DATA to appear like they still have capacity. Destroying your existing files (and showing a slow write speed as they have to do it in this slow, unorthadox way). This is not conclusive, so back up data and scan the card in a PC, preferably a dual-boot Windows-linux one with exFAT support, if exFAT is the filesystem used on the card. Then perhaps try formatting the card and testing it with proper tools. Test the card: using automated tools, write to the whole card, read back the results as uncorrupted), sdcard.

Test with: https://fightflashfraud.wordpress.com/download-h2testw-free-and-test-flash-memory/

https://cubiclenate.com/blatherings/fightflashfraud/

Note: even genuine flash can fail in time and has a write-cycle limitation. Always backup data (in at least two other locations, plus your working copy on the card) ASAP. Everything is expensive on an Indian salary, so if you can afford a camera, afford a decent, non-fake, TESTED card. With technology, I find that as long as the minimum speed is reached, reliability, not speed, is king!

-5

I use extreme plus editions for 100megabytepersecond video recording 4k. Sandisk is okay now 2019 as there have been no hiccups. I researched usbC flashdrive and invested a hundred bucks for high end terabyte very tiny sized external. Contents gets moved from sdcard into ssd usbC hosted by galaxyS10+ pie. This defense assumes ssd lasts forever. It does. But understand "moving" contents out from the sdcard physically destroys the material since zeroes are rewritten onto the physical content area. Each cycle doing this writing zeroes actually is death warrant.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.