5

I want to buy some ND grad filters but am unsure whether to purchase the Cokin a-series or p-series. I prefer smaller and lighter equipment because it is easier to transport and since my lenses (18-55mm and 55-200mm) both have a 52mm filter thread, is there any disadvantage to buying into the a-series rather than the larger p-series?

5

The 18mm focal length of your wider lens would show the filter holder in the frame, if you used the A-series. Cokin themselves only recommend using the A series for 36mm focal lengths and above, but if you're using a cropped sensor camera you could probably get away with 24mm. Even the P-series are recommended for 28mm and longer, but again that would probably be more like 18mm on a cropped sensor, so you may just get away with it.

The P-series filters and holders aren't really too cumbersome, and even if you are restricted from using the wider end of your 18-55mm zoom, that would be less of an inconvenience than having to lug around and pay for the very expensive X-Pro or Z-Pro series.

  • I use the Cokin P system (albeit by a different manufacturer) with my 18-55 and the holder doesn't show even at the wide end (that's on a DX format camera). – ElendilTheTall Apr 3 '11 at 14:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.