I use a Metabones adapter for Canon lenses on a Sony body. Why doesn't the lens adapter, which sets the lens further from the sensor, have the same effect as using extension tubes, allowing closer focus?

  • It should. What in the results differs? – loonquawl Sep 12 at 14:58
  • 1
    If by "lens adapter" you mean what is essentially an extension tube with optical elements in it, then they don't do the same thing because of what the optical elements add to the total lens equation. – twalberg Sep 12 at 15:01
  • 2
    @twalberg No, something like this - a glassless adapter. The Metabones ones are optically the same, just add some clever electronics for autofocus, aperture control, IS etc. – Philip Kendall Sep 12 at 15:12
  • 1
    If it allows for closer focus, then you won't be able to focus to infinity. Most people prefer being able to focus to infinity so adapters are designed like that. However, there are adapters that has adjustable length to allow both close and infinity focus. – user3528438 Sep 12 at 19:09
up vote 27 down vote accepted

Because the Canon EF mount lens "expects" to be further from the sensor than a Sony E mount lens; this is known as the flange focal distance or the registration distance - a Canon EF lens focuses the incoming light on a plane 44mm behind the lens, while a Sony E lens focuses it on a plane 18mm behind the lens.

If you somehow bodged it horribly so that a Canon lens was mounted in the same place as the Sony lens, it would be focusing everything on a point 26mm behind the sensor and it would all be a bit of a disaster really. The EF to E lens mount adapter ensures that the Canon lens is mounted 44mm from the sensor so that the incoming light is focused in the correct place.

  • Indeed. If I recall correctly, that's also the reason why you can mount nikon F lenses on canon EF but not the other way around. And it's also the reason why it will be possible to mount any full frame lens on the Nikon Z. – Eric Duminil Sep 13 at 14:26

Why don't lens mount adapters have the same effect as extension tubes?

They do. But whether it limits far-focus capability depends on one factor: the difference in distances from the image plane to the back of the lens mount flange between the two systems.

If the adapted lens's mount is deeper than the camera's mount, the adapter tube can make up the difference so that the lens sits exactly where it needs to in order to have full range of focus.

If the adapted lens's mount is shallower than the camera's mount, then the adapter is working exactly like an extension tube and will reduce far-focusing capabilities, if there's no glass element. If there is a glass element in the adapter, the adapter no longer acts like an extension tube, but is now acting like a converter lens, where the added glass has changed the apparent focal length to regain focus-to-infinity. The Speedbooster acts like a wide converter, which decreases the focal length (and increases the DoF and max. aperture). But other adapters often use a teleconverter lens to increase the focal length (which decreases the max. aperture).

See also: Can I use lens brand X on interchangeable lens camera brand Y?

The Metabone adapter is an optical accessory that mounts between the camera body and the camera lens. Such a mounting relocates the lens further forward. Such repositioning corresponds precisely like the action of extension rings or tubes in common use. However rings and tubes are void of lenses whereas the Metabone adapter contains lenses that modify the focal length of attached lens.

Supplemental optics similar to this device has been in use almost from the beginnings camera / lens design. We can mount such devices before or after the camera lens. These devices alter close focusing distance or they modify the lens, converting it to a telephoto or a wide-angle.

Many such supplemental lenses have been or are currently being marketed. The Metabone adapter revises the focal length of the attached lens, it shortens it about 70%. In other words, say a 50mm lens is combined with a Metabone adapter. The 50mm focal length is altered, it converts to become35mm. This action is analogous to add-on wide-angle converters commonly available. However, most such devices mount before the camera lens whereas the Metabone adapter mounts after the camera lens. Again, not a new idea.

How does the Metabone adapter realize a lens speed increase? The photographic industry uses the f-number system to specify the relative speed of a lens. The camera lens acts like a funnel in that it gathers light. The greater the working diameter of the lens (aperture) the brighter the projected image (speed of the lens). Entwined with aperture is focal length. Both are contributors as to how bright the projected image will be. Say the aperture diameter is untouched and the focal length doubled the projected image dims to 25% of its original brightness (2 f-stops). Conversely, if the focal length cut in half, the image brightens 2 f-stops.

The Math: 50mm lens 12.5mm aperture = f/4 --- 100mm lens 12.5mm aperture = f/8 --- 25mm 12.5mm aperture = f/2

Suppose you set your 50mm to f/8 achieved with a 6.25mm aperture. Now you mount a Metabone that shortens the focal length 70%. The revised focal length is35mm. The aperture remains unchanged at 6.25mm, the revised f-number is 35 ÷ 6.25 = 5.6 (written f.5.6). Simply stated, the Metabone shortened the focal length, this act increased the angle-of-view (more wide-angle), the image brightened as a result, the revised f-stop is f/5.6 = 1 f-stop speed gain.

The cleverness of the Metabone is, it shortens the focal length, this gives rise to a speed gain plus it adapts a lens designed for a larger format camera to operate on smaller format cameras mitigating the crop factor that would normally charge. Remarkable is the fact that back-focus distance (flange focus distance) of the lenses is corrected taken into account allowing lens interchangeability.

Also, Meabone is credited with suppressing some aberrations normally realized when a supplemental lens is added. (If all true, hats off to the optician

  • 2
    You're confusing the Metabones adapter (glassless) with the Speedbooster (glass). The question is about the adapter. – Philip Kendall Sep 12 at 22:51

Extension tubes don't have any lens elements; they're completely hollow. Metabones adapters do have lens elements.

  • 2
    The Speedbooster does, but not the T Smart Adapter – Tim Hopper Sep 12 at 19:47

Your Answer

 
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.