I want to do long exposures of the Perseid meteor shower this weekend using my Canon AE-1 manual film camera. I don't have a manual cable release. Are there other hacks/ways to hold the shutter open for a long time (minutes)?

  • I tried a few shots without much success this weekend, but it still was fun. – LucasMcGraw Aug 13 at 14:28
  • The hangover to it: Sorting through all the exposures and distinguishing aircraft of some description (the bastards tend to be similar in streak length on 30" exposures) from actual meteors.... – rackandboneman Aug 13 at 23:51
up vote 6 down vote accepted

Just go to a local camera shop and pick one up. They're under $10.

A hack - Use black electrical tape and a 1/4" long piece of wooden dowel (or some other similarly sized object). Place the piece of wood (or whatever you can find that works) over the shutter button and then just tape it down.

  • 6
    to avoid camera shake while taping down the button you could keep the lens cover over the lens before pressing down the button and only removing it once you're confident the shutter is properly pressed. At the end just put the lens cover back before trying to remove the tape – SztupY Aug 10 at 18:56
  • That'll sure be annoying if a person is taking more than a couple of shots, but it would work. – Jim MacKenzie Aug 10 at 20:10
  • Or maybe an elastic band over the shutter? Less messy than tape anyway. – vclaw Aug 12 at 11:17
  • Or jamming a pin/bolt/... into the cable release socket... – rackandboneman Aug 14 at 0:00

You can hold it down with your finger. That's the only other option.

Cable releases are inexpensive and easy to get. Your only issue might be the tight timeline you've left yourself, but if you have local camera stores, there's a very high probability that they will have manual cable releases in stock.

Some cameras have a T or Time setting (your camera has a B or bulb setting, where the shutter is kept open only as long as you hold the button). T will open the shutter with one click and close it with another. However, relatively few modern cameras have this feature, and your camera is not among them.

There's no real practical way to take very long exposures with most 35mmm film cameras¹ other than by using a mechanical shutter release cable. Holding the shutter button down with your finger will very likely cause camera movement. If there are no camera stores that carry them in your area and you don't have time to order one from various online sources, you might try checking with any local camera clubs to see if anyone has one they'll either sell to you or loan to you for the evening.

A film camera is probably not the most suitable tool for capturing a meteor shower unless you have a very large film/development budget. You are going to need to take a very large number of shots to have a decent chance of capturing anything.

To capture meteors effectively you need to:

  • Increase sensitivity (ISO) until the light gained is offset by the increase in noise. Digital cameras do much better than 135 film camera at the sensitivities needed to capture meteors effectively. Most of the dimmer meteors you do manage to include in the camera's field of view when your shutter is open will be swallowed up by the film's grain when shot at sensitivities of ISO 1600-3200 or beyond.
  • Increase aperture as much as possible without losing significant sharpness. For some lenses this will be wide open, for others it might mean stopping down anywhere from 1/3 stop to a full stop or more.
  • Decrease the amount of time the shutter is open. If you are using a 24mm lens with a 35mm camera, the star trailing will begin to be noticeable for an 8x10 print with exposures longer than about 25 seconds.²

These settings will allow the meteors to be brighter in relation to the stars. The stars are dimmer than the brightest meteors, but that brightness is constant over the entire time of a long exposure. Meteors, on the other hand, don't last very long and move across the frame rather rapidly. The longer your exposures, the dimmer the meteors will appear relative to the brightness of the stars.

It is then a numbers game: Set up your camera to take continuous shots. Out of several hundred frames you might catch a few good meteors and a few more that are visible!

The image below is my best capture from the 2012 Geminid shower. Over several hours I wound up with almost 400 exposures. I got one great shot and 3-4 other confirmed Geminids. I also got a couple more that I thought were meteors until discovering their paths and appearance times matched known satellites in orbit!

(For best viewing use a dark background or view full screen. The white background used by stack exchange prevents your eyes from seeing the details!)

enter image description here

¹ There were a few 35mm film cameras that used electrical, rather than mechanical, cables to control the shutter remotely. (The Konica FS-1 that was my first SLR was one such camera. It also had an electronically controlled vertical travel metal shutter and a built-in 2.5 fps motorized film drive.) A few older film cameras had a 'T' mode that opened the shutter with one press of the shutter button and closed the shutter with the next press of the shutter button.
² Divide 600 by your focal length to get the longest exposure that won't make star trailing noticeable with an 8x10 inch viewing size when not using a tracking mount for your camera.

  • You raise some valid points. Thank you. What was the ISO/exposure time on your wonderful picture above? – LucasMcGraw Aug 13 at 14:27
  • EOS 5D Mark II + EF 17-40mm f/4 L at 17mm. ISO 1000, f/4, 30 seconds. Exposure pulled 2/3 stops in post, along with contrast reduced. Now I would probably use ISO 1600 and 15-20 seconds to shoot meteors. That would be a little too bright for this one, though. This one was a huge fireball to the naked eye. Most are considerably dimmer than it was. – Michael Clark Aug 13 at 14:53
  • Probably most AF film SLRs have electronic shutter release instead of a cable release socket ... however, there seem to be modern DSLMs (some Fuji models at least) that feature actual cable release sockets... – rackandboneman Aug 14 at 0:04
  • @rackandboneman Both the AE-1 referenced in the question and the Konica FS-1 referenced in the answer were 'pre-AF' era cameras that required manual focusing. – Michael Clark Aug 14 at 8:16
  • Yep I am aware of that ... was referring to "there were a few 35mm film cameras", which would include AF film cameras :) – rackandboneman Aug 14 at 14:07

Just use your imagination:

  1. Use sticky chewing gum to press the holder, before removing the caps put in front of the lens a black cardboard, wait for 2 to 4 seconds and then remove it.
  2. Expose for as long as you want.
  3. Put back front of the lens the black cardboard. Remove the chewing gum from the shutter.

Now you got a proper bulb mode to use when you don’t a manual cable release for a classic film camera. Well, proper, proper it’s not, but it’s the McGiver method aka the poor man solution.

Your Answer

 
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.