Serene Life

by garik

submit your photo


Hall of Fame
View past winners from this year

Please participate in Meta
and help us grow.

Take the 2-minute tour ×
Photography Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professional, enthusiast and amateur photographers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I was wondering if it is right to say that underexposing or overexposing by playing with shutter speed or aperture or ISO is the same as dialing in -+EV values in manual exposure?

share|improve this question
    
let me be more specific.I am talking about Manual mode. –  V.B Mar 16 '13 at 9:29
    
Which camera? Many DSLRs have two command buttons, and one will adjust shutter speed, the other aperture. Canon Rebels have a command dial that adjusts shutter in M mode, and you use the exposure compensation button to set aperture (but you're not really setting EC, rather just using that same button to set aperture - EC doesn't apply) –  MikeW Mar 16 '13 at 10:41

3 Answers 3

up vote 7 down vote accepted

If you are using an automatic exposure mode (e.g. Program mode, Aperture or Shutter-priority) then dialing in +/- exposure compensation tells the metering system to adjust the exposure up or down. Otherwise it will always attempt to produce the same exposure for the same scene.

If you are in Manual mode, then you accomplish the same thing by simply adjusting ISO, shutter speed or aperture. The camera isn't automating the exposure, so you don't have to tell it to adjust - you have complete control, and the camera will ignore any EC setting.

So if you have the camera set to some combination of ISO, aperture and shutter speed, then dialling in EC will not have any effect on those settings in M mode - they will still apply and you'll get the same exposure (there is at least one exception - on some Nikons, if you have Auto ISO enabled then dialling in EC will adjust ISO, which will affect your exposure)

Dialling in EC may affect the exposure indicator in the viewfinder (on a Nikon anyway).

An example - let's say you're taking your sunset photos.

  • Camera is set to ISO 200, f/5.6 and 1/125th second. Looking through the viewfinder, the exposure meter indicator is zeroed out. You take a picture. It's well exposed, but you want it a bit darker to get better color.

  • In manual mode, you change the aperture to f/8. The meter now displays that you are underexposing. You take the picture anyway, and it looks good.

  • Still in manual mode, you change the exposure compensation down a stop. Now the meter is zeroed again. However this won't affect the exposure, just the display in the viewfinder. Take another picture, it will still be f/8, 1/125th, ISO 200, same as last time, so same exposure.

  • Because the indicator in your viewfinder is zeroed out, and you have the amount of underexposure you want, as it gets darker, you can use the indicator (keep the meter zeroed) to adjust your aperture.

So EC can be used indirectly to help you maintain a constant amount of compensation, but it does not directly affect the exposure in Manual mode.

share|improve this answer
    
so if I have understood you right, say I am trying to underexpose sun rise,I can either play with Shutter speed,ISO aperture or can simple dial in a -ve EC value? –  V.B Mar 16 '13 at 9:32
    
Yes. In manual mode, you can just keep adjusting until you get the exposure you want. Or in auto modes, dial in - EC. –  MikeW Mar 16 '13 at 10:05
    
Nikon models: i have experienced that changing the +-EV value in Manual mode does nothing. You can over/under expose only by using Aperture/Shutter or ISO controls..... –  Darklantern Mar 16 '13 at 11:47
1  
The EC-dial still affects the exposure meter, though does nothing to the exposure in itself. MikeW's example is a nice one, and it works just like that even in my 33 years old film SLR. I'd suppose the same of any modern camera, not only Nikon. –  Esa Paulasto Mar 16 '13 at 13:48
3  
The exposure compensation is worthwhile in manual because it affects the meter reading. If you're only nudging things a fraction of a stop, you can just set the reading to, say, -2/3 by adjusting the shutter/aperture/ISO, but if you're aiming for a couple-three stops up or down, you lose the meter's help without EC and are stuck metering "straight" then doing calculations/counting clicks. It's not hard, but it is easier to make mistakes. (In the '70s, I'd use the ASA/ISO dial to do the same thing—the film doesn't actually change speed, so the ISO dial was the EC dial.) –  user2719 Mar 16 '13 at 17:38

let me get it in simple words for you gentlemen ....

When you mean underexpose/overexpose you are exposing the sensor by physically controlling the light by adjusting aperture , shutter speed and ISO(in film days)

Using exposure compensation we are controlling the light digitally.(cannot be done in film days)

:)

share|improve this answer
    
Many automatic film cameras also offer exposure compensation, which is also effected by changing the aperture or shutter speed. –  mattdm Mar 17 '13 at 13:56
    
a information i did not know :) thank you mattdm .... but what i was trying to refer is, that it was intended to reduce light without digital aid for underexposure and over exposure. but for the exposure compensation, it mostly avoids physical restriction of light as of now in the digital world. –  pradeep sekar Mar 18 '13 at 8:34
    
Can you explain that a little bit more? Do you mean to say that EV compensation on digital cameras primarily works by boosting gain, not by adjusting the exposure program (including aperture and shutter speed)? Can you give an example camera which works that way? –  mattdm Mar 18 '13 at 13:44

No, it is not the same thing, although as operator/photographer you may do exactly the same thing with your hands in most cases.

Exposure compensation is a way to compensate for mis-measurements of the build-in meter in order to achieve the expsure value that you want. It is typcially done to avoid under- or over-exposing. On the contraray, you do that to expose right.

Under- and overexposing are not really tasks, things you do. It is rather an evaluation of the result. An underexposed image turns out (partly) darker than you want it. You will compensate for that by either using the exposure compensation or adjusting the manual settings. That is up to you.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.