Alley in Pisa, Italy

by Lars Kotthoff

submit your photo


Hall of Fame
View past winners from this year

Please participate in Meta
and help us grow.

Take the 2-minute tour ×
Photography Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professional, enthusiast and amateur photographers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am looking at getting a DSLR. I have a little experience with a film SLR but not much more than the basics. I plan to take a range of photo types.

My research has narrowed down the products to the Nikon D5000 and Nikon D90. On paper they look relativity similar with the main differences being a few more on body controls, the physical size and better kit lens of the D90.

My question is that are the differences worth the extra cost for a beginner will I out grow the D5000 too quickly?

share|improve this question
1  
Duplicate of Are there disadvantages to a prosumer camera for a beginner, aside from cost?, which generalizes the question and keeps it relevant in years to come. –  mattdm Nov 10 '12 at 15:42
add comment

10 Answers 10

up vote 18 down vote accepted

Go to a physical shop and feel both cameras. While the advice in other answers is good (don't buy features you don't need), ergonomics are important, both size of the body and placement of the controls and just how it "feels". For example, I haven't seen a D5000, but I've handled a D40 and it felt like cheap junk. On the other hand, the D90 feels like a well-built machine. This is something you have to see/feel for yourself.

However, don't go to a camera shop, look at their stuff, and then leave and buy it online. That's unethical.

You might find it a bit more expensive to go this route, but the opportunity to make a better decision and your confidence in that decision is worth it IMO.

Finally, the kit lenses are just fine.

share|improve this answer
    
I have been to the shop and the D90 does feel more robust than the D5000 though it is significantly bigger and 200g heaver –  John Jul 26 '10 at 20:41
    
Bigger and heavier is a good thing. –  Bobby Ketchum Aug 15 '10 at 6:47
3  
@Bobby, not necessarily. Depends on the use. –  Reid Aug 15 '10 at 14:59
add comment

For me the deciding factor to get D90 is build-in Autofocus Motor which is absent in D5000.

Many good affordable prime lenses require that the camera has an in-body AF motor, for example:

Using those lenses on D5000 would mean that you need to rely on manual focus

share|improve this answer
1  
+1 as this is the reason I chose my D90. I did have the budget so it was not a money issue but a needs issue. I also purchased body, lense, sb-600 flash separately –  Wayne Jul 29 '10 at 5:53
add comment

If you are beginning, most DSLR will work pretty fine for you. Unless you really don't mind the extra cost and weight, go for the Nikon D5000 and a better lens.

A better lens like a prime 50/1.8 or any other fast lens (faster means lower aperture numbers, like 1.8 or 1.4) are probably going to render you better chances of getting a good picture with a good enough body (which the D5000 is more than).

By the time you have mastered (I don't think "out grow" would apply here) the D5000, there will be plenty of choices on the market for you stepping up. By the way, by then a D90 will probably be quite affordable.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I actually was in the EXACT same boat you are in 7 months ago, I initially purchased the D5000 because it was cheaper without too many other considerations. After using it for a month, I returned it and decided to purchase the D90.

  1. The ability to use commander mode and fire an off-body flash. (SB-600 for me).
  2. The internal focusing motor.

The commander mode was the biggest thing for me. Using an off-body flash has come in handy quite a number of times and gives you a bunch more lighting flexibility.

share|improve this answer
    
On a side note, I went the body-only route and separately grabbed the 16-85mm as my basic lens and have added a number of lenses since. –  theChrisMarsh Aug 12 '10 at 0:12
add comment

For learning/beginner, I recommend getting a used D90 or D80, or even cheaper still a used D40. You can get a complete used D40 with 2 lenses (18-55 and 55-200) and usually cards, bag, etc for under $450 and probably $500 for used D80 with a lens (18-70 or something like it).

They do not have videos, but they have plenty of life to learn from in photography. If you have extra money, invest in lenses instead of bodies.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I made the exact same decision 6 months or so ago, and I chose the D5000. It ended up being about $200 cheaper.

The one big difference is the lack of an internal focus motor on the D5000. If you think you are likely to want to use older lenses, you will not be able to autofocus with them on the D5000. For me, this wasn't a big issue, but it might be for you. The one lens I was looking at that might have been an issue is the AF 50mm, which is super cheap, but it won't AF with the D5000. Physically, I didn't see much difference between the two, the D5000 was a bit smaller and lighter, which I preferred.

Personally, I would at least try to wait another couple weeks, it does sound like the D90 replacement is pretty close to coming out. The video on both of them is not all that useful right now, and supposedly that is one thing that the replacement will fix.

share|improve this answer
2  
I have a d90 and the video is garbage. Decent enough to give your mom an idea of what was going on at some weird time, but not for anything serious. I wish they would've cut the price of the D90 and left out the video –  Jody Jul 30 '10 at 2:59
    
@Jody : these are not video recorders, you can't ask that much. –  Andrei Rinea Oct 18 '11 at 12:07
add comment

When you saw the differences between the cameras, did any of them make you think 'Yeah, that could come in handy' or were you struggling to see how they would help you? I don't think there's much point splashing out on extra features that you won't use.

The other consideration is the lens; my advice would be to buy the body only, and get a separate lens as kit lenses are generally not that great, even on higher spec cameras. There's another question on this site about what lens a beginner should get; check out some of the answers there, and bear in mind that if you get the cheaper body, you can spend more on a decent lens, which in the end is often more important than the camera when it comes to image quality.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Additionally, according to rumours the D90 will be replaced soon with a newer model: http://nikonrumors.com/2010/07/20/first-word-on-the-nikon-d90-replacement.aspx

share|improve this answer
2  
So when it comes out you may be able to pick up the D90 at a bargain price as shops clear their stock of the old model. I did this buying my Canon 40D once the 50D was out and got it for less than the 500D. –  Hamish Downer Jul 26 '10 at 13:07
add comment

According to B&H:

I know you can get the D90 kit for 1000$ in the US, but since I am not familiar with the discounted price for the D5000 I will disregard this.

Although the 18-105 is an excellent lens the difference is too much. You can buy the D5000 and a seperate 18-105 and still stay below the D90 kit. The D5000 is certainly sufficient and strong for a beginner. The only reason I would recommend going with the D90 kit is in the case the lens would have made it worthwhile (since you can use it with future bodies).

Since the dry math calculation does not make it worth I don't think you need to strech yourself.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I just purchased a used Nikon D80 with a Nikkor 18-135 from craigslist for $500. If cost is an important factor, I'd recommend looking used. There are great opportunities out there. You could even take the money you saved and spend it on extra lenses. After all, DSLR bodies aren't like the old film cameras - they aren't lifetime purchases. It'll become obsolete while the lenses will prove useful for much longer...

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.